Showing posts with label Feedback. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Feedback. Show all posts

Sunday, 14 March 2010

Teacher Feedback (Rough Cut 2):

Our second rough cut was generally well received by Mrs. McCluckie in comparison to the rest our efforts, most notably our first attempt at a rough cut. The change from Jack miming in the verses to more narrative based scenes was seen as a vast improvement. This rough cut however is by no means perfect, and we know that. Scenes Miss did pick up on include;
  • The shots of the two of us holding hands reveals that it is a homosexual love affair too early on, due to the hair on my arm. Therefore that needs to be re-filmed.
  • The scenes whereby Jack gets up to go to the bathroom and where he is getting dressed are too long and monotonous. We planned to rectify this by breaking these shots up with a variety of cuts, featuring the party or flashbacks.
In addition there are a few shots we don't personal like and some of the editing needs tweaking, but apart from that it seems we are finally near the end of the process.

Thursday, 25 February 2010

Teacher Feedback (Rough Cut):

The footage we got from the 10/02/10 helped us make a short rough cut. We made the verses more interesting by adding in various small montages, relating to the sexual act that took place. In addition Jordan edited together a chorus which featured Todd Cook and Jack Clegg miming the chorus. Here he used various different editing techniques to make it less monotonous, which was one of Mrs. McLuckie's main criticisms of our previous footage. He did this via a variety of split screen shots and by quickly swapping the camera angles, to give it a distorted effect.

We then showed Mrs. McLuckie, and let's just say she was less than pleased with our efforts. Reviewing the whole video again she basically scrapped all our footage. Criticisms included; Jack's performance was not good enough, the lighting was bad, the shots were too static, in some cases there was too much going on and the party scenes were not executed well by various party goers ruining the shot by jumping up and down behind the protagonist. However she did like the juxtaposition of the young boy and Jack, and the use of split screen editing.

It was a shock to all of us we thought that we were on the right lines, and with the deadline in four weeks it was a massive push back. But of course Mrs. McLuckie knows what she is talking about, and it is her opinions that will help us achieve the A grade us all so desperately want. The consensus was that we had a great idea, but have not really executed it well. So it was back to square one, we had to rethink the whole video.

The first thing we unanimously decided was to scrap Jack miming the verses completely and fill them with narrative based shots. But keep him miming on the chorus, which will focus more on the young boy segments. Now the story will focus more on the morning after, or just hours after the protagonist has had sex. Therefore it will be him waking up, slowly realising what he has done, and soon regretting his actions.

He will wake up to be greeted with the sight of clothes on the floor and a condom wrapper, clearly illustrating what has just happened. Consequently he tries to relax himself with a cigarette, and then goes into the bathroom to cleanse himself thoroughly. Before getting dressed and making his way downstairs to the after effects of a party, so people clambered over the floor, mess and drink everywhere. Upon seeing who he has just slept with he goes crazy breaks out the house, collapses outside the front door in a crying state, consequently leading to the last scene which will see him reunited with his one night stand, and conclude on an image of the two kissing. All this will be in twined with short flashback shots of the night before, as well as random images, which we have used previously.

Initially the idea was that the protagonist was going to storm out of the house running down the street before collapsing, and then being faced with his one night stand. However Mrs. McLuckie ruled this out, because rarely does a scene featuring running work out well, and it would be extremely hard to film. Therefore we tweaked the ending slightly. Furthermore Miss picked up on several shots which featured animal masks, and it was suggested that this should be presented as one of the main themes of the video. Initially the masks were meant to represent the fact that the person the lead sleeps with is unknown, as well as the protagonists hidden identity as a homosexual. It still will, and we will try and nod at the masks in each scene, whether it is subtle with the mask just resting on the bed, or Jack looking in the mirror to see himself with a mask on.


Another criticism of our video was that there wasn't a given style; the lighting constantly seemed to fluctuate, so on the next shoot we will try to maintain a continuous lighting pattern that will reflect the mood of the story. Also we need to film more of the young boy scenes, so it makes more sense to the viewer as to what is going on, as well as maintaining the juxtaposition with the protagonist.

Tuesday, 9 February 2010

Teacher Feedback 2:

Editing together our footage from 1st February proved reasonably successful; we had enough shots to make a satisfactory introduction. The introduction has come out exactly the way we intended. It features the strobe lighting, the quick editing, the sexually suggestive cuts, and it all flowed perfectly to the music.


Satisfied with the introduction we then edited a rough first verse together. On completion we decided to show Mrs McLuckie what we had done so far, to see if we were going in the right direction or if we will need to scrap it all completely and film everything again.

Evidently the introduction seemed to receive praise. However the same can't be said for the first verse. Criticism was that the shots were too static and monotonous. The consensus was that the introduction would catch the viewer's attention, but they would drift away before the end of the first verse. Additionally we decided to get a second opinion and show several of our peers, and it was unanimous that the introduction was fine, but the first verse needed a little tweaking.

It wasn't the end of the world we were on the right track, so we went back to final cut and made the first verse more interesting by adding in small montages in between various cuts to keep audiences hooked.

After we completed the first verse we looked at our footage for the chorus, and felt it wasn't good enough, it faced the same problem it was too static and boring. Furthermore we kept recycling the same montage clips. So it was obvious we had a lot more to film.

On the next filming trip we will need to film the verses again, the choruses, plenty of short random clips as well as sections of the storyboard we haven't even started to film. It sounds taxing yet possible.

Tuesday, 15 December 2009

Teacher Feedback:

Once we had are basic idea we told our teacher; Mrs McLuckie, to get relevant feedback, so we could build on our ideas. Or discard them completely if it was bad. Overall it was good feedback she liked the idea, particularly the twist at the end. But her main concern was setting. Although whatever we make will look amateurish, because we obviously haven't got the budget or resources to make an 'amazing' video, we can try our best with what we have got so it looks professional to some extent. So the choice of filming it in a house was considered as a hindrance, because that usually automatically rings A level school project. It is an easy way out, and often looks very amateurish. Furthermore it was too focused on the narrative and we needed to add in some spontaneity, random images to disjoint the video.

We went back to the drawing board and discussed possible locations; we discussed various clubs, and pubs that would work. But the problem with using anywhere like that is of course gaining access, and directing the people in there. It was unfeasible, as far as we were concerned. As appealing as a 'professional' setting such as a club sounded it wasn't really an option. So we decided to make a conscious decision and stick with our guns to film it at a house party. We have seen a few videos filmed at house parties that still look visually exciting (notably; Lady Gaga's Just dance).



We then discussed random and intriguing concepts to add into our video. I came up with an idea that everyone at the party is wearing a different animal mask, so you can never see who the lead is talking to. However the cost of obtaining these masks would have been expensive, so we had to disregard that notion. But there were some ideas discussed that we will try and maintain, which you can read about in the following 'scene by scene' post.